Thursday, August 4, 2011

Mystery Painting - Maine Coast

Mystery painting, signed "JTW 1870" lr 
(sorry I don't have a higher res pic)

Here's a painting that's a bit of mystery. It came up for auction last year and sold for around $1500, a decent sum for a painting of unknown origin. It's signed "JTW" and dated 1870 by the artist. Period paintings by shadowy or forgotten artists abound in small auctions all over the country (this one was from Julia). Sometimes they can be had for a few hundred bucks. Because I love the tradition of 19th century American landscape painting, I find these auctions a great source for inspiration for my own work.

Maybe someone knows who "JTW" was, but the auction house couldn't pin him down and neither could the dealer who bought this and then sold it to a patron out of his gallery. 

In the absence of the "brand value" attached to a "name" artist (i.e., a "listed" artist, whatever that's supposed to mean), a painting has to stand on its own merits. I believe this "mystery" painting fetched such a tidy sum because of sheer quality alone - the artist could lay claim to no marketing cache whatsoever. So in what does that vague word "quality" consist? Let's look at the painting.

First of all, it's a timeless subject - waves crashing into a rocky shore (it's clearly Maine - there's a market for "Maine paintings," which is part of the reason this particular dealer purchased and successfully resold it). It's not just waves on a shore, though. Not only does the ocean's force careen compellingly across the picture plane, but the wave itself is huge - or, rather, long - and it occupies an unusual quantity of real estate (for a wave) in the center of the forward picture plane. "JTW" adds to the drama with strong, balanced contrasts between light and dark. 

Along with the dramatic (Baroque) lighting, I think the wave's sheer bulk and its upward thrust contribute the most to the "feeling" that's evident in this painting, which has something to do with a recognition of the power and beauty of raw nature (which would be the painting's "true" subject - i.e., that which it makes one feel). 

There's plenty of detail in this painting, all executed with obvious skill. That's key. But the other thing it's got is "atmosphere." Look how the entire right-hand triangle of the diagonal composition is a swirl of nebulous mist and light! It looks like the primal creation of the world out of chaos in there! I'm a big fan of atmosphere in painting. 

Maybe this isn't a "great" painting, deserving of a place in the pantheon of the highest human creations of all time (if it had been signed "Bierstadt," though, or "Church," would it be a different story?). But I wanted to share it because I just really like it and wanted to write about it to discover why. 

My rather fanciful theory, it turns out, is that it delivers a poetic response to nature's power and beauty, marrying the clarity one expects with the mystery one wants to believe in.


  1. It's quite beautiful, thanks for posting it so we all can see.

    I like that the mystery of not knowing who painted it.

  2. I'm with you in thinking the atmosphere is very well done. "A swirl of nebulous mist and light.." Yeah!

  3. "the clarity one expects with the mystery one wants to believe in" Exactly, and well put! The very thing I admire in paintings and what I strive for in my own work.

    I too am always on the look out for great paintings by "artist:unknown" at estate sales, auctions and even flea markets!

    This was beautiful find thanks for sharing!

  4. Katherine- me too. It definitely adds a wistful, other dimension for me knowing this fellow human lived and died and ... now there's this.

    Jan - tell me more about your quest. Any favorite finds? I sometimes browse the Hollis Flea Market but while I see lots of old paintings, I find the really intriguing high-quality ones are rarities.

  5. Wonderful color harmony. Nice mood, too.
    Didn't know you had a blog going. Really nice.

  6. Looking historically and comparatively Ray Ban Glasses at some Coach Outlet Store longitudinal projects in community based arts in New Jordan Shoes 2020 health, the article assesses what makes for both success and failure in practice, and looks particularly at the significance of the arts in helping to deliver strategies for improving child health and education. In a strategic development context, explanation is given of several strands of university community Coach Outlet collaboration in arts in health, with interlinked project examples drawn from Tyneside and West Yorkshire. Finally, the article looks at the prospects for sustaining arts in health within the coming transfer of the public health function to local government..

    That's all we have from this game. To Yeezy Discount me, it was the opening spell from Gabriel and Roach in the Ray Ban Outlet last hour of the second day which played a major role in the match. Sri Lanka fought hard in the second innings, but it was always a herculean task. Long term institutional care in the UK is provided by care homes. Residents have prevalent cognitive impairment and disability, have multiple diagnoses Coach Handbags Clearance and are Yeezy Boost 350 subject to polypharmacy. Prevailing models of healthcare provision ad hoc, reactive and co ordinated by general practitioners result in unacceptable variability of care.