Tuesday, November 17, 2026

How Great Paintings Mean: Andrew Wyeth's portraits and "Morning Sun"




Andrew Wyeth,
Morning Sun, Dry brush on paper, 13 1/2 x 21. 1959


Quick sketch in umber: title "Morning Sun." Dark African-American figure, dark background, and a sharp, angular shard of light where the paper's left blank. The man in the picture seems to turn toward the light, but his body language - he's almost cringing - says he cannot embrace it. 

Andrew Wyeth did this watercolor anticipating eventually painting the man's portrait. But what interests us is that it's not so much a study for the final painting (it looks nothing like it) as it is the record of a moment of "vision." This painting is the encapsulation of an insight in something he saw. As a "study," it surely yielded Wyeth information for what he was eventually going to "put in" to the larger finished work. And yet, on its own, it's a visual poem, a testament, an entire swath of history, a whole damn symphony and epic novel in miniature. 

Wyeth wasn't just making a picture, no matter how sensitive, of someone he knew. He wasn't painting the man at all. He was painting a vision, a dream in the precise shape and texture of that man in that barn on that bed. "I have such a romantic fantasy about things," he said, "and that's what I paint, but come to it through realism." Not "under the surface" but through the surface, he was painting a cluster of nameless, emotion-filled ideas in a way that others, who knew how to read them, could feel them too.

At a crucial point the artist made the decision to give over 75% of the composition to shadow. Why? It wasn't just for a dramatic Caravaggesque effect. Nor was it only because he loved painting backgrounds so much, although we do know that he did, and more on that below. 

No, in that dark well of shadow behind the figure of the man crouched on the bed dwells all the dark of loneliness and frustration, oppression, and not belonging. By virtue of how the dark background dominates the figures and the entire composition, how the figure is situated in the middle not of the picture plane but in the middle of the shadow, by how the darkness then looms over the figure - these were the visual cues the artist would use to evoke his meaning. In a lesser artist's hands, the light of morning "streaming in" would signify hope, beginnings, a New Day and all that. But not here. That brittle, cut-off blank is like a piece of broken glass. 

The light is glaring, and the man raises his shoulder almost defensively against it. In fact, it's light but also a void; there's nothing on that part of the paper except what looks like a few pencil marks. What about those stripes of shadow against the man's back? That's an unusual choice in Wyeth's portraits, in which the principal figure, like the one below, is generally represented in a shifting, ambient light. In old film noir movies from the 1940s and '50s, stripes of shadow falling across a figure symbolize the eventual "prison" or trap - the double-cross, the set-up - closing in on the character. Could there not also be an echo of the violence of slavery and the brutal lashes of history, the callous and dreadfully casual abuse that man inflicts against his fellow man over and over again?

Without this background the figure would still be expressive, but the painting as a whole wouldn't be as powerful or effective. Great artists find out how to evoke more than they describe; they sense a meaning in the motif, as you would in a dream, a fusion of image and idea. Paintings make visible the immaterial through the material, someone said. A background in any great painting is never just "what was there."

It was in his backgrounds, Weyth said, that he could often dream most freely. "After I get in the mood of a thing I'm painting, I love to work on the background," he said in a 1959 interview. Specifically he was referring to the portrait below. This painting, titled "The Patriot," is a portrait of another acquaintance of his, a former military man. "In this portrait of Ralph," he said, "it isn't just a dark tone to show off the head."


     Andrew Wyeth, The Patriot, Oil on canvas, 1959

"It's actually a world - it's the thunder of the Meuse-Argonne (the largest and bloodiest battle in US history, fought in northeastern France in 1918, where the man fought vigorously). It's the dirt and mud he stood in the trenches. It's the tobacco he chews, the smell of the wood in his sawmill. I love to dream, to think about this thing that's going to live in the background. It's the most exciting thing."

You don't have to have "deep thoughts" all the time to see things like this. We see them every day. You just have to pay attention to what you see, what you feel, and what you know.

Most of the time we go through life reacting to whatever's immediately coming at us. We're like wild animals spurred on by the Darwinian dictates of survival: chasing the next goal, heading off potential disaster, trying to remember something to deal with later, facing immanent obstacle X and fiercely protecting asset Y. 

Art says stop.

Art, looking at it and making it, reminds us we're missing something, and it's not just the smell of the roses. We're missing our whole inner life. Mostly the "random thoughts" ideas, fascinations, dreams, desires pass right by to be forgotten. Thing is, they aren't random at all. Those are the very things that make us who we really are. 

Those odd curiosities, those quiet "ah-hah" moments of sudden compassion, nascent insight and ordinary awe intruding into the everyday - the glow of light through a lemon slice, the odd fact you learned about possums, why you like old black and white movies. Those are the moments when the static on the radio stops and the station comes in.

Artists who continually manage to create great works throughout their lives dedicate themselves to these moments of clarity. They recognize them when they happen as the lightning flashes they are, and they turn them first into ideas for art, and then they wrestle them into existence in actual artworks, often through a painful and time-consuming process of trial and error.

And with that, here's a couple closeups of "The Patriot's" army jacket - when Wyeth said "realism," he meant it. It's almost as if he'd painted every thread.





       DETAIL: Andrew Wyeth, The Patriot, Oil on canvas, 1959


No comments:

Post a Comment